HC Deb 11 July 1904 vol 137 cc1197-8
DR. THOMPSON

To ask the Secretary of State for War if he is aware of the dissatisfaction existing amongst the officers of the Royal Army Medical Corps at the recent promotions, whereby twelve senior officers were passed over in favour of a younger officer of less distinguished service than some of those whose claims were rejected; and if, in future, he will direct the Advisory Board to give their reasons for their selections and communicate them if requested to the officers passed over.

(Answered by MR. Secretary Arnold-Forster.) The Secretary of State is not aware of the dissatisfaction amongst the officers of the Royal Army Medical Corps alleged in the Question. Promotions are made by selection and after careful inquiry by the Advisory and Selection Boards. The standard upon which the Advisory Board bases its recommendations is that of positive merit, and suitability for the Administrative Medical Staff of the Army. It would not appear desirable that reasons for supersession should be communicated to the officers affected.