HC Deb 14 August 1896 vol 44 c836
MR. J. P. FARRELL

I beg to ask the Chief Secretary to the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland whether any memorial has been recently received praying for the discharge from the Philipstown Reformatory of Joseph Carney, a boy of 16 years of age, who at a recent quarter sessions in Longford was sentenced by Judge Curran to five years' detention there for stabbing a companion in a quarrel; and whether, seeing that this lad has now been for more than one year in the reformatory, and that his father, who is a car owner, is in a delicate state of health, and unable to follow his trade of car driving, he will recommend that the boy may now be discharged with a view to assisting his parents?

MR. GERALD BALFOUR

No memorial has been received since November 1894. Detention in a reformatory cannot be regarded merely in the light of a punishment, and I do not think any special circumstances exist in this case to make the boy's discharge desirable.