Clyde Estuary Development Study

HC Deb 04 December 1968 vol 774 cc1508-10

12. Mr. Galbraith

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland in view of the size and complexity of various major projects such as that of Murco which are now envisaged in the Clyde area, if he will arrange for a comprehensive public inquiry covering all such projects rather than that each should be considered separately.

39. Mr. John Robertson

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if, before any decisions are taken, he will publish the proposals for the comprehensive development of the Clyde and West of Scotland areas and allow the widest possible pubic discussion of such proposals and submit them to the House.

Mr. Ross

The Clyde Estuary Development Study was commissioned to focus consideration of such issues. There will be a full opportunity for public discussion before planning decisions are taken on any major new industrial proposals within the ambit of the Study and, so far as possible, related issues will be considered together. I cannot at this stage say whether it will be appropriate to bring any of these proposals before the House.

Mr. Galbraith

in studying the report will the right hon. Gentleman bear in mind that the development of industry along the Clyde estuary will not only be highly damaging to tourism but will also mean that inland towns will be denuded of industry? Would it not be better to see that industry is brought to the people rather than vice versa?

Mr. Ross

There is a balance of considerations in all these things, but we must not jeopardise too readily the prosperity or possible increased prosperity of the Clyde..

Mr. Robertson

Is my right hon. Friend aware that many members of the public are apprehensive about rumours of what is proposed and that some kind of public statement is required fairly soon? Does he also accept that, of all those involved in the discussions, it is only the elected representatives of the people in this House who have not had the opportunity of knowing what is proposed?

Mr. Ross

I hope that we shall get the report of the Clyde Estuary Study in a few weeks' time. But there is little one can do about rumours except to point out that people should wait until they get firm information about what is really afoot.

Mr. Noble

In view of the enormous possible importance of this development to the Clyde area and the very large number of interests involved, will the right hon. Gentleman do his best to publish the first report he has available so that the people know what is being planned and need not rely on rumours?

Mr. Ross

The decision about publication of the report is not for me but I expect the Steering Group of the commissioning authorities to publish a report as soon as possible.