HC Deb 02 June 1965 vol 713 cc1686-7
2. Mr. Hamling

asked the Secretary of State for Defence how he proposes to apportion the cost of clearing oil from the English Channel on 28th March, 1965.

The Under-Secretary of State for Defence for the Royal Navy (Mr. J. P. W. Mallalieu)

In the exceptional circumstances, and without prejudice to future cases, the cost will be borne by Navy Votes. Since the subject has been raised, I am sure the House would wish to acknowledge the promptness and efficiency of the Royal Navy in dealing with this occurrence.

Mr. Hamling

Will my hon. Friend, on behalf of all Members, convey the thanks of the House to the Navy, not only for the expeditious way in which the operation was conducted, but because of the fact that so many men gave up leave to carry out this operation? Are we to understand that the taxpayer is involved to the extent of many thousands of pounds? Is he not aware that the ships involved in the collision were insured? Surely, insurance ought to have covered the cost, and not the taxpayers' money.

Mr. Mallalieu

The cost of the operation was £8,618. We have had a look at the possibility of a claim, but we are advised that one does not lie.

Mr. Hay

Will the Minister accept that we on this side of the House would like to be associated with that tribute to the Royal Navy, and will he accept our congratulations on what must be a noteworthy victory over the Treasury?