HC Deb 06 May 1957 vol 569 cc618-9
21. Mr. Champion

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food whether he will take steps to call the attention of all farmers to the cruelty entailed in the shooting of deer with unsuitable weapons or ammunition, or at ranges which are too great, or by inexpert shooters, and in failing to follow up and dispatch wounded deer.

Mr. Godber

My right hon. Friend thinks most farmers are already aware of this, but he will certainly do what he can to remind them of these points.

Mr. Champion

I hope that the Minister will press this matter, because there have been distressing reports of animals being wounded and left to die and being found in maggot-ridden condition.

Mr. Godber

We would certainly deplore that. If the hon. Gentleman will give us details of such cases, we will try to follow them up where we can.

Mr. Paget

Would not the Minister agree that shooting inevitably involves a percentage of wounded and is always much crueller?

Mr. Godber

That might well be the case, but I cannot be drawn into question and answer on the relative values of shooting and hunting.

22. Mr. Champion

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food whether he will instruct pests officers to ensure that, when deer drives are organised, only competent shots shall take part, that unsuitable weapons and ammunition shall not be used, that supervision shall be in the hands of an experienced shot, that wounded animals shall be followed up with tracker dogs and humanely dispatched, and that all concerned shall be instructed in the steps requisite for ensuring a minimum of cruelty.

Mr. Godber

Pests officers seldom organise drives against deer, but when they do, steps are taken on the lines suggested to avoid cruelty. My right hon. Friend will gladly remind them of the points mentioned by the hon. Member.