HC Deb 25 January 1956 vol 548 cc195-7
25. Mr. Patrick Maitland

asked the Minister of Transport and Civil Aviation the number of accidents, fatal and causing bodily injury, respectively, which have occurred each year since the war on the Stirling-Carlisle road opposite Burnwood Camp, Carluke, Lanarkshire.

Mr. Molson

As the Answer consists of figures, I will, with permission, circulate it in the OFFICIAL REPORT.

Mr. Maitland

In thanking my hon. Friend for that rather uninformative and unforthcoming Answer, may I ask him whether he will give some indication of the trend of the figures?

Mr. Molson

In the last ten years there have been one fatal casualty and six nonfatal casualties.

Mr. Maitland

Can my hon. Friend say what they were due to? Is there a common cause?

Mr. Molson

No, Sir. They were due to divergent causes.

Following is the Answer:

ACCIDENTS INVOLVING PERSONAL INJURY ON THE STRLING-CARLISLE ROAD AT OR NEAR THE ENTRANCE TO BURNWOOD CAMP, CARLUKE, LANARKSHIRE
Fatal Non-fatal
1946 1
1947
1948
1949
1950
1951 2
1952
1953
1954 1
1955 1 2

26. Mr. Patrick Maitland

asked the Minister of Transport and Civil Aviation the circumstances in which a fatal accident took place on the Stirling Carlisle road opposite Burnwood Camp, Carluke, on 18th December, 1955.

Mr. Molson

I am informed that this accident resulted from a collision between a 3-ton lorry and a 14-cwt. van. The driver of the van was killed and his son, who was a passenger, seriously injured. The accident is to be the subject of a fatal accident inquiry which will be held by the Sheriff under the Fatal Accidents Inquiry (Scotland) Acts. My hon. Friend will appreciate that until the inquiry has taken place it would not be proper for me to comment.

Mr. Maitland

Is my hon. Friend aware, and will he draw the inquiry's attention to the fact, that it has been widely stated that this accident, like others before it, was due to a pothole which has been in this road for fifteen years, and is not it possible to fill up a pothole?

Mr. Molson

I have no doubt that many statements will be made before the inquiry, and that in cases where such things can be substantiated evidence will be produced.

27. Mr. Page

asked the Minister of Transport and Civil Aviation upon what considerations he bases his decisions to hold or not to hold an inquiry into any particular road accident.

Mr. Watkinson

Investigations into road accidents are carried out by the police in the normal course of their duties. Serious accidents involving goods vehicles or public service vehicles are also investigated by officers of my Department. An inquiry under Section 23 of the Road Traffic Act, 1930, is held when it seems desirable to investigate more closely the causes of a particular accident, especially where it seems likely that such an investigation may suggest measures for obviating similar accidents in the future.

Mr. Page

Has not the power under Section 23 been used very sparingly in the past years? Does not my right hon. Friend think that he could obtain more information from detailed inquiries into a number of road accidents, in the same way as railway accidents are inquired into, rather than by relying on the rather unreliable statistics of the police?

Mr. Watkinson

I will certainly look into that matter, but I cannot give an answer now.

Back to