HC Deb 16 March 1953 vol 512 cc1825-6
53. Mr. Chapman

asked the Minister of Transport what correspondence he has had with Mr. James Edwards of 71, Woodlands Park Road, King's Norton, Birmingham, about Mr. Edwards' invention of a life-guard to be fitted to the front of motor vehicles in order to prevent fatal accidents on the roads; what have been the reasons for delay in trials of the guard in Birmingham; and whether he will arrange for official testing and examination of the invention by his Department.

Mr. Braithwaite

Mr. Edwards wrote to my Department last year about his invention, and the Department also replied to a letter of his to the Prime Minister. Devices of the same kind have been tried out before. I am not satisfied that they would effectively reduce fatal accidents on the roads but, while I do not think that an official test of Mr. Edwards' invention would be justified, we have no objection to any tests he may arrange privately, provided they do not conflict with the law.

Mr. Chapman

Is the Minister not aware that his Department placed obstructions in the way of the test in Birmingham on some rather small ground about exceeding the length of the vehicle? As this invention is an addition to the vehicle, how can the test be carried out unless the inventor receives some help in this respect?

Mr. Braithwaite

One of the difficulties is that the effect of being struck by a guard of this kind is very similar to being struck by the wheels themselves.

Mr. Chapman

Is not the Minister saying that this could be tried in Birmingham but he is, in fact, not giving facilities for it to be done?

Mr. Braithwaite

I am saying that it can go forward as long as the law is not infringed.