HC Deb 21 July 1949 vol 467 cc1529-30
4. Mr. Sutcliffe

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will reconsider his decision refusing permission to local authorities to demolish air-raid shelters which, although not dangerous to health, have become a nuisance to people in adjoining houses.

Mr. Ede

I regret that I do not feel justified in withdrawing the general instructions that have been issued to local authorities about the removal of shelters, but I should be glad to consider any case which presents special features if the hon. Member cares to let me have particulars.

Mr. Sutcliffe

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that the problem would be solved if he would allow local authorities to brick up the entrances, and that at the present time wooden doors and barriers are constantly being pulled down?

Mr. Ede

I do not feel that in the present state of the world it would be wise to abandon the provision and maintenance of these shelters. I am quite willing to consider specific cases, but I think that the general decision must stand.

Mr. Shurmer

Is my right hon. Friend aware that this will cause grave disappointment, especially to people who live in small courtyards and terraces in the City of Birmingham where these air-raid shelters take up almost every bit of room where children could play or where people could hang out their washing; and is he further aware that his inspectors are not very helpful in Birmingham?—because I have tried them.

Mr. Ede

I should have thought that after the experience of Birmingham in the last war, the people there would be reluctant to abandon any safeguards that may be necessary. I am always willing to consider cases in which the public health or safety may be involved.

Squadron-Leader Fleming

If a local authority so decides, has it the right to brick up the entrances to these shelters?

Mr. Ede

No.