HC Deb 18 September 1940 vol 365 cc152-3
29. Mr. Gallacher

asked the Minister of Supply whether he has made an estimate of the increased extra cost to be borne by his Department on the basis of the increased rates for which the railway companies are now applying?

Mr. H. Morrison

The preparation of an estimate of the kind the hon. Member has in mind would require special inquiries and investigation of prices, which I do not think I should be justified in having undertaken at the present time.

Mr. Gallacher

Does not the Minister feel that it would be quite right for his Department to make such an estimate, and to join in the public opposition to the demands of the railway companies?

Mr. Morrison

After consideration, I have taken the view that it would not be appropriate that the considerable time that would be involved should be utilised by the Ministry for this purpose.

Mr. Shinwell

While appreciating that there would be some difficulty in making an estimate of the kind asked for, I take it that it is to be assumed that my right hon. Friend is concerned about a possible increase in freights?

Mr. Morrison

Yes, Sir, to the extent that the Ministry of Supply would be involved in the movement of transportation, but I think it would be unwise to divert the energies of my officers to the considerable labour of finding out these figures.