HC Deb 08 October 1940 vol 365 cc239-41
28. Miss Rathbone

asked the Home Secretary whether he has considered the case, details of which have been sent to him, of a man who was detained in prison for 10 days, then ordered to leave the protected area in which his home and employment were situated, in consequence dismissed from a permanent pensionable post with a local authority, without an opportunity being given him to know the nature of or to rebut the charge against him and without the authorities taking up any of the references supplied them to persons occupying high administrative positions who were willing to testify to his good character and loyalty; and whether he will undertake to allow this man and other persons similarly penalised and disgraced, to submit their defence to some tribunal or advisory committee similar to that which deals with British citizens detained under security regulations?

Mr. H. Morrison

The restriction order made against this man was revoked by my predecessor after full inquiry had been made into the case. I am in full sympathy with my hon. Friend's desire that opportunities shall be available for persons against whom restriction orders' are made of hearing what are the grounds for such restrictions and of clearing themselves, if they can, of suspicion. For this purpose it is desirable that there should be local inquiries in or near the place of residence of the person affected by such order, and I am arranging that there shall be available in the several Regions men of legal experience to whom such cases can be referred for investigation.

Miss Rathbone

While thanking the right hon. Gentleman for his reply, may I ask him to use his influence with the local authority which dismissed this man, or otherwise he will be completely ruined, and give some assurance that he is exonerated from the grave charges made against him which are now proved to be unjustified?

Mr. Morrison

I have looked up the papers in this case, and I do not think I should be justified in making such representations in view of the fact that, to put it mildly, this man was exceedingly foolish and indiscreet in a number of statements he made.

Mr. Davidson

With regard to regional inquiries, will they extend to Scotland?

Mr. Morrison

The Home Secretary cannot answer for Scotland. [HON. MEMBERS: "Yes."] If that is so in these matters, Scotland will be included.

Miss Rathbone

Will the right hon. Gentleman make further inquiries into this case?

Mr. Morrison

I am afraid that I do not think it proper for me to take further action in this case.