HC Deb 06 March 1940 vol 358 cc359-60
7. Mr. G. Strauss

asked the Prime Minister whether, in view of the great indignation in the United States over the search, on 18th January, of the Pan-American Clipper in the Bermudas, he can make a statement on the matter?

Mr. Butler

Under international law, a belligerent is at liberty to examine any mail, whether neutral or belligerent, which is brought voluntarily within its jurisdiction. His Majesty's Government decided to exercise this right at Bermuda, as from 18th January, in respect of East-bound mails carried by the Pan-American-Atlantic service.

Mr. Strauss

Is it not a fact that, as a result of the Government's action, there has been great indignation among the West Indian public at the fact that the service no longer stops at Bermuda. In those circumstances was not the action of His Majesty's Government a very serious blunder?

Mr. Butler

I do not accept that at all. I think the action of His Majesty's Government was correct and justified, especially in view of what was discovered in the mails.

Mr. A. Henderson

Could His Majesty's Government, in agreement with the United States Government, consider whether it is possible to evolve some sort of arrangement which will satisfy the needs of His Majesty's Government and remove the fears of a large section of American opinion?

Mr. Butler

I am glad that the hon. and learned Gentleman put this Supplementary Question. It is always our desire to find some form of settlement which is agreeable to both nations.

Mr. Strauss

At the moment, I suppose, the Government have no control at all over these aeroplanes which stop at Bermuda?

Mr. Butler

We do not own the airport where they now come down.