HC Deb 02 May 1933 vol 277 cc664-5
44. Mr. ALBERT RUSSELL

asked the Prime Minister whether his attention has been called to the position of the Scottish linen manufacturers in whose industry the wage rates are regulated by a trade board and who, in tendering for Government contracts, are handicapped in competing with Northern Irish manufacturers whose wage rates, not being so regulated, are considerably lower; and whether, in order to remedy this, he will take steps to insure that in respect of Government contracts for flax, hemp, and linen, it will in future be a condition that the wage rates payable shall be not less than those fixed by the Flax and Hemp Trade Board of Great Britain?

The PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY to the MINISTRY of LABOUR (Mr. R. S. Hudson)

I have been asked to reply. I am aware that wages in the Irish linen trade are not regulated by a trade board, but I have no evidence that the wages generally are lower than the trade board rates in Scotland or that the effect on contracts has been as suggested.

Miss HORSBRUGH

If it can be proved that the rates are a great deal lower, will some consideration be given to the trade in Scotland?

Mr. HUDSON

That is a matter primarily for the trade board concerned in Scotland.

Miss HORSBRUGH

Will it not be taken into account in connection with Government contracts? If through the trade board in Scotland the wages are considerably higher than the wages in Ireland, will some arrangement be made by the Government for dealing with these contracts?

Mr. HUDSON

A Government contract contains the fair wages clause. The fair wage in Scotland is the trade board wage, and presumably the fair wage clause in Northern Ireland is equally applicable, and the fair wage is the wage arrived at through the negotiating machinery.

Mr. RHYS DAVIES

What happens if there is no wage regulation machinery?

Mr. HUDSON

I understand there was a trade board originally in Northern Ireland, and that it was withdrawn on the setting-up of wage negotiating machinery in Northern Ireland.