HC Deb 06 February 1930 vol 234 cc2072-3
66. Mr. FREEMAN

asked the Minister of Health whether he has considered the present method of the maintenance of lunatics in large institutions and in private asylums, and whether he has considered their maintenance in cottage homes as an alternative; and, if so, does he propose to take any action in the matter?

Mr. GREENWOOD

I am advised that the majority of patients cannot be suitably provided for except in institutions, but the question of boarding out in rural districts patients of the quieter type is under consideration. My hon. Friend will, however, appreciate the difficulty of the matter in present circumstances.

Mr. SCRYMGEOUR

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware of the very weak results of placing patients in such large institutions in contrast with private establishments?

Mr. GREENWOOD

I am prepared to discuss that with my hon. Friend but I am afraid his facts are wrong.

Captain GUNSTON

When are we to have the Mental Treatment Bill?

Mr. GREENWOOD

As soon as possible, I hope.

Mr. FREEMAN

Why is it that they can only ho kept in large institutions as at present?

Mr. GREENWOOD

It is very difficult to reply briefly but, clearly, these are cases which require the expert assistance of people who understand mental diseases.