HC Deb 19 November 1928 vol 222 cc1385-6
70. Mr. LUNN

asked the Secretary for Mines if he will state the estimated percentage reduction in the cost of production of coal produced in Yorkshire due to the de-rating proposals?

Commodore KING

On the basis of the latest available information, the estimated average reduction in the cost of production of coal commercially disposable in Yorkshire due to the de-rating of the collieries themselves would be about 4d. a ton, or 2½ per cent.

Mr. LUNN

Does the hon. and gallant Gentleman think that that will rehabilitate the industry in Yorkshire?

Commodore KING

No, but what I have stated must not be taken into account apart from the reduction of freights owing to the de-rating of railways.

Mr. T. WILLIAMS

Does the hon. and gallant Gentleman suggest that 75 per cent. of the rates paid by colliery companies in Yorkshire is equivalent to 4d. per ton?

Commodore KING

Yes, that is the question I am answering. Owing to the de-rating of the collieries it will be about 4d. a ton.

Mr. WILLIAMS

Is the hon. and gallant Gentleman aware that the average rates paid by collieries in Yorkshire are less than 3d. a ton, and that 75 per cent. of that cannot be 4d.?

Commodore KING

I am not aware of it, and obviously it cannot be, true.

Mr. AUSTIN HOPKINSON

Is the hon. and gallant Gentleman aware that if the anticipations of savings in the cost of production by the de-rating both of railways and collieries are anything like fulfilled, they will place by far the greater proportion of Yorkshire production on a paying basis?

Forward to