HC Deb 10 July 1918 vol 108 cc285-6
Sir HERBERT ROBERTS

(by Private Notice) asked the Leader of the House whether an opportunity will be given to discuss the proposals in connection with Indian reforms before the House adjourns in August?

The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER (Mr. Bonar Law)

I am, of course, always ready to meet the wishes of the House if they are communicated through the usual channels. I think, however, that, in view of the length and importance of the Report, the discussion should not take place too soon.

Mr. CHARLES ROBERTS

Does not the Leader of the House think that perhaps, in the course of three weeks, the House will have this Report more clearly in its mind than if it postponed its consideration till October, when very likely it will not? [HON. MEMBERS: "NO!"] May I attempt to show—[HON. MEMBERS: "No!"] May I ask whether the Leader of the House thinks it desirable to postpone both the discussion on the Indian Budget this year and all consideration of this Report?

Mr. BONAR LAW

Of course, whether or not there is time to study it depends on what hon. Members have to do. It certainly will require a great deal of study before it is possible to form an opinion about it. I express no statement as to the date. I only express the view that we ought certainly to have some reasonable time.

Colonel WEDGWOOD

Will the postponing of the discussion of this subject by the House in any way interfere with the discussion of the subject by the Cabinet, or will the discussion of it go on in the Cabinet without regard to that?

Mr. BONAR LAW

The Cabinet will certainly consider it as they have opportunity, but I think it was stated when the Report was issued that one reason why we issued it at once was that we had not the time to give it the necsesary consideration, and I am certain we shall not have that time before the end of the Session.

Colonel WEDGWOOD

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that every day discussion of this reform is postponed makes the affairs of India more difficult and makes the loyal co-operation of India with this country more difficult?