HC Deb 21 November 1917 vol 99 cc1161-2
12. Mr. LEES-SMITH

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs at what date he became cognisant of the declaration made by M. Ribot to the French Chamber of Deputies that the Czar of Russia had promised M. Briand, when Prime Minister of France, that he would, in addition to supporting the French claim to Alsace-Lorraine, leave France free, if need be, to make an autonomous state out of German territories on the west bank of the Rhine?

Mr. BALFOUR

I received the text of M. Ribot's statement on 1st August.

Mr. LEES-SMITH

Was the right hon. Gentleman aware of that statement when in the Debate on peace negotiations he described my reference to it as an absolute mare's nest?

Mr. BALFOUR

The hon. Member misinterprets what I said. Perhaps he had better put a question down and I will consider it. One of the things in this con- nection which I said was a mare's nest was the idea that one of the war aims of the British Empire was to create a new autonomous territory on the Rhine.

Mr. LEES-SMITH

Does the right hon. Gentleman recollect that my statement was distinctly that it was an agreement between Russia and France, and that I specifically said it was not an agreement in which this country was concerned?

Mr. KING

If the right hon. Gentleman does not know in November what was communicated to him officially in August, is not that an instance of his delay?

Mr. BALFOUR

On the hon. Member's own statement, that is not delay, but forgetfulness.

Mr. KING

Is not forgetfulness in a Minister just as bad as delay?