§ 13. Mr. LYNCHasked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs whether he is aware that with regard to the proposed exchange with Germany of civilian 1094 citizens over military age, many of whom are invalids at health resorts, reports have been spread in Germany that the difficulty has arisen from the failure of the British Government to welcome reciprocity in the matter; whether any unwillingness on that score exists; if not, whether a clear expression will be given of a desire to come to terms for mutual advantage; and whether the matter will be expedited as much as possible either by direct action or by employing the friendly offices of representatives of neutral Powers?
§ Mr. C. ROBERTSI am aware that reports of the nature indicated have been spread in Germany, but there is absolutely no foundation for them. As long ago as 17th September His Majesty's Government undertook to release German subjects not of the age for military service—i.e., under seventeen and over fifty-five years of age—provided that the German Government would reciprocate, and an agreement was reached forthwith. Further, on 8th October, His Majesty's Government proposed to the German Government that an agreement for the mutual exchange of the medically unfit should be concluded. They have recently caused the German Government to be reminded of this proposal, and stated that they will act in accordance with it as soon as assurances are received from the German Government that they will adopt a similar course. Hitherto this and other similar offers have been refused by the German Government. With regard to the last part of the question, direct communication between His Majesty's Government and the German Government is not possible and the negotiations have throughout been conducted through the medium of the United States representatives, who have spared no pains in their efforts to arrange a satisfactory settlement.
§ Mr. LYNCHHas the right hon. Gentleman made it clear to the representatives of friendly Powers that the detention of these citizens is unimportant from a military or diplomatic point of view, and is simply a case of cruelty?
§ Mr. ROBERTSI understand the Secretary for Foreign Affairs will be here tomorrow, and will be glad to give any further information; I would suggest that any further inquiries should be addressed to him.