HC Deb 14 September 1909 vol 10 cc1921-2
Mr. LUPTON

asked the First Lord of the Admiralty if he will abandon the practice of making revaccination compulsory for candidates for employment in the dockyard, having regard to the statement by the Royal Commissioners on Vaccination, in their Final Report, paragraph 419, that the occurrence of a febrile illness is the desired result of vaccination, and that it is sometimes attended by eruption?

Mr. McKENNA

I am considering the conditions under which vaccination on entry in the dockyards is made compulsory; but, in view of the difficulties of consultation during the period of the year ordinarily devoted to holidays, I am unable to promise my hon. Friend any early conclusions.

Sir GILBERT PARKER

Do we understand that the Admiralty are considering the abolition of vaccination?

Mr. McKENNA

No, Sir; I cannot go beyond what I have actually said—I have been considering the conditions under which vaccination on entering the dockyards is made compulsory.

Mr. LUPTON

The right hon. Gentleman will be aware that already some of the Government Departments have relaxed their old-fashioned rules?

Mr. McKENNA

Yes; I believe that in certain Government Departments the question has been brought up for special consideration.

Mr. ARTHUR LYNCH

Would the right hon. Gentleman be favourable to the appointment of a Special Commission to reconsider the whole question of vaccination?

Mr. McKENNA

I do not think that would apply particularly to the Admiralty.