HC Deb 27 July 1909 vol 8 cc994-5
Mr. GEORGE GOOCH

asked the Under-Secretary for India whether the Secretary of State had yet received official information as to whether the cases of the nine British subjects who were deported from Bengal last December without charge or trial have now been reconsidered by the Government of India; and, if so, with what result?

Mr. J. D. REES

asked the Under-Secretary for India whether the cases of the nine deported Bengalis came up this month for reconsideration by the Government of India, or were merely reported in the manner prescribed by the Regulation as a matter of administrative routine?

The MASTER of ELIBANK

The Regulation requires the officer, in whose custody a State prisoner is, to submit twice a year a report to the Government of India on the "conduct, health, and comfort" of such State prisoner, in order that the Government of India may determine whether the orders for his detention shall continue in force or be modified.

Mr. GOOCH

May I ask whether it is not also obligatory on the Government to consider the whole policy of the deportation of these prisoners, and not merely their detention?

The MASTER of ELIBANK

I have quoted entirely from the Regulation.

Mr. RAMSAY MACDONALD

Are we to understand that the Government of India is not reconsidering the policy that has been pursued?

The MASTER of ELIBANK

I do not think that arises out of the answer.

Mr. MACKARNESS

How much longer will they have to be detained; can the right hon. Gentleman say?

The MASTER of ELIBANK

No, Sir, I am afraid I cannot.