§ Mr. T. L. CORBETTasked the Chief Secretary whether his attention has been called to the case in the Belfast summons court brought against P. J. Courtney, on 11th November, 1909, for illegally supply- 498 ing drink; whether he is aware that the I resident magistrate, Mr. Brady, commented adversely on the decision of the magistrates in dismissing the case; and whether the Government intend to take any action in the matter?
§ Mr. BIRRELLI am informed by Mr. Brady that this case was heard by him and several other magistrates. In announcing the decision of the court he reviewed the evidence, and stated his own opinion but did not comment on the views of the other magistrates. The case having been dismissed no further action can be taken in the matter.
§ Mr. SLOANDoes Mr. Brady object entirely to the verdict given by his brother magistrates on the bench, and, in view of the fact that this is a perfect scandal in Belfast, will the right hon. Gentleman take care that the bench will not be packed in this way in future?
§ Mr. T. L. CORBETTIs the right hon. Gentleman aware that the resident magistrate said, "I think it very regrettable that such a decision should be arrived at by the bench," and that the members on the bench at the moment were practically all appointed by the right hon. Gentleman's Government?
§ Mr. BIRRELLI have no knowledge who appointed the magistrates. Differences of opinion frequently occur between magistrates in various parts of the Kingdom.
§ Mr. SLOANMay I ask whether he is aware that this abuse was carried on long before the present Government came into power?