HC Deb 21 May 1908 vol 189 cc516-7
MR. J. DEVLIN (Belfast, W.)

I beg to ask the Secretary to the Treasury whether the late Treasury Remembrancer, Sir Robert Holmes, had still a year to serve in his office before he could be retired under the 65 rule; whether he had, before he resigned his office, accepted a directorship of the Bank of Ireland; whether this was contrary to the regulations of the Civil Service; and whether the fact that this resignation had been received or tendered was not announced to the public, in order to keep the applications for the office confined to a small area of Treasury clerks.

Mr. HOBHOUSE

Sir Robert Holmes will attain the age of sixty-five in December next. He intimated to the Treasury in March last his desire to resign, and he was only retained in office after his election as a director of the Bank of Ireland until his successor could be appointed. It is not usual to announce such resignations to the public; and there is no foundation for the suggestion in the last paragraph of the Question.

MR. MOONEY

Did Sir Robert Holmes, while still a Civil servant, inform the Treasury that he had accepted the appointment of a director of the Bank of Ireland, or did the Treasury first get the information from an outside source and call on him to resign the Remembrancer-ship?

MR. HOBHOUSE

I understand that Sir Robert himself communicated to the Treasury the fact of his election, and they did not first learn it from an outside source.

MR. MOONEY

Did he inform the Treasury of his intention to become a director before his actual appointment?

MR. HOBHOUSE

I understand that he did so.

MR. SWIFT MACNEILL

Is there not a distinct rule in the Civil Service precluding any Civil servant from becoming a director of a public company? Why was Sir Robert allowed to remain after he had accepted such a position?

MR. HOBHOUSE

He only remained for the convenience of winding up the business of his office, and then it was for but a fortnight.

MR. SWIFT MACNEILL

When Mr. MacCartney was appointed Deputy Master of the Mint he had to resign his directorship on the London and North Western Railway at once.