§ 11. Mr. Colvinasked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food how many dairy farmers have gone out of milk production as a result of the non-marketing and conversion scheme since it came into operation.
§ Mr. MacGregorThe final report by the Commission on the non-marketing and conversion premium schemes indicates that nearly 123,000 applications were approved under these schemes in the period July 1977 to December 1981. In addition, a small number of applications were approved after 1981. In the United Kingdom there were some 8,300 successful applications under the scheme.
§ Mr. ColvinWill my hon. Friend say how many of those farmers, having taken substantial compensation, are now back in dairying? Would it not have been a great deal better if the five-year limit had been a 10-year limit? Has the European Commission made any more acceptable proposals for limiting milk production, proposals which would stand a better chance of working and would be fair to British dairy farmers, who are the most efficient in the world?
§ Mr. MacGregorI regret that no statistics are available about those who have come back in, as the scheme required producers only to give up milk production for a maximum period of five years. It is probable that a number have come back in, and that is one of the many criticisms that could be made of the scheme, which I do not think was cost-effective. The Commission has not come forward with proposals, but in view of our criticisms of the operation of the scheme we should look critically at any such proposals.
§ Mr. Robert HughesWill the Minister discover how many farmers have come back into dairying, as I understand that it is an accelerating process?
§ Mr. MacGregorI shall certainly look into that. Because we do not have the information, we should have to send out further surveys. I shall have to look into that aspect. In view of what I said—that the scheme no longer exists and that we should be critical of any scheme in anything like that form—I hope that it becomes an academic question.