§ 13. Mr. Doigasked the Secretary of State for Scotland how many persons were murdered in Scotland in each of the last three years; and how many persons were murdered in Scotland in each of the three years prior to the abolition of capital punishment.
§ Mr. Harry EwingIn 1973, 1974 and 1975 the recorded numbers of persons murdered were 39, 34 and 41, respectively. In 1962, 1963 and 1964 the numbers were 25, 15 and 27, respectively. All the figures have been corrected in the light of judicial determination.
§ Mr. DoigIs there not a clear indication from these figures that capital punishment does have a deterrent effect and, therefore, should be considered seriously once more by the Government?
§ Mr. EwingNo, I do not agree. The statistics indicate that the incidence of murder in Scotland, like that of many other crimes, has increased over the last decade. It is not realistic to base any conclusion about the effectiveness or otherwise of capital punishment as a deterrent on the figures for one country over a short period of time. However, we are very concerned about the preservation of law and order and we are giving a great deal of attention to it.
§ Mr. FairbairnCan the Minister tell us what proportion is represented by serious assaults which result in deaths?
§ Mr. EwingNo. If the hon. and learned Member wants such detailed information he should table a Question.