HC Deb 12 November 1975 vol 899 cc1520-1
15. Mr. Dempsey

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he will call for a report regarding the condition of equipment used for the administration of general anaesthetics in general dental practices in view of the findings of a recent inquiry arising out of a death.

Mr. McElhone

No, Sir. I am aware of the recent tragic case to which my hon. Friend refers, but there is no reason to believe that this is a general problem. A dentist in general practice is required by his terms of service to furnish his surgery with suitable equipment and I am satisfied that dentists generally fulfil this requirement.

Mr. Dempsey

Is my hon. Friend aware that the inquiry report established that this equipment was in a non-satisfactory condition? I have a letter from the dental officer of the area health board saying that that board has no responsibility to ensure that such equipment is kept in a proper condition. Is my hon. Friend aware that, following the report of this tragedy, the pathologist stated that it was dangerous to give a general anaesthetic to someone in an upright position? As the professionals seem to have different opinions on this matter, will he pursue it and clarify the situation for the benefit of all concerned?

Mr. McElhone

My hon. Friend has made three points. The inquiry returned a formal verdict in this case. There are conflicting views within the profession about administering anaesthetics in different positions. Some of the problems associated with general anaesthesia and dental practice are at present being examined by a joint committee of the National Dental Consultative Committee and the Anaesthetic Sub-Committee of the National Medical Consultative Committee.

It is for the area health board concerned to decide whether the circumstances in any particular case warrant reference to a service committee. I understand that in this case the matter has yet to be considered formally by the board. Therefore, I am not in a position to say what action, if any, it may decide to take. I shall write to my hon. Friend when I receive the information.