HC Deb 12 December 1974 vol 883 cc749-50
13. Mr. Lane

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether he is satisfied with the operation of the capital gains tax as it affects householders; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Joel Barnett

I assume that the hon. Member is concerned about the liability to capital gains tax that may be incurred by a householder who lets part of his home. Complete exemption from capital gains tax for the residential owner occupier extends only to a house which is wholly owner-occupied. It was never the intention that it should extend to parts of the house not used by the owner as his home.

Mr. Lane

Will the Minister take a fresh look at the serious situation in Cambridge and other university towns where householders are increasingly hesitant about letting the odd room or two for lodgings because of the capital gains tax problem, coupled with uncertainty resulting from the Rent Act 1974? Should not it be within the wit of the Treasury to find a commonsense solution that will increase the supply of badly-needed lodgings without breaching the principle of the capital gains tax?

Mr. Barnett

I am aware of the problems of students in Cambridge and elsewhere, but I should be surprised if capital gains tax were the major problem for landlords and landladies.

Mr. Evelyn King

Aside from the problems of householders, is it not a fact that in the existing disastrous economic climate there are likely to be more capital losses than capital gains? Is not this the right moment to abolish the tax?

Mr. Barnett

No, Sir.