HC Deb 03 April 1973 vol 854 cc205-6
4. Mr. John Hall

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services what representations have been made to him following the publication of the results of recent research which indicate that mothers who have had a previous abortion are more likely to have a stillborn, premature or defective child; and if he will make a statement.

The Secretary of State for Social Services (Sir Keith Joseph)

None, Sir. But I am glad that the Lane Committee will be considering this matter.

Mr. Hall

Is my right hon. Friend aware that the evidence so far produced shows that of children born to mothers who have had one abortion, about 200 are seriously handicapped, about 2,000 are likely to have mild defects and about 1,000 are stillbirths, and that it is estimated that between 2 per cent. and 5 per cent. of women who have had an abortion are likely to be sterile? In view of all this evidence, is it not time that my right hon. Friend reviewed the operation of the Abortion Act to make sure that abortions are limited to cases of medical necessity and are not resorted to merely to save social embarrassment?

Sir K. Joseph

I have a great respect for the two authors of the report to which my hon. Friend refers, but they are non-medical and there are possible shortcomings in the evidence and conclusions which make it unwise to depend entirely upon them. But there is a need for further research, and I am glad that the Lane Committee will be considering the views of the Wynns and will, I hope, be making its report to the House later this year.

Mr. William Price

Has the Minister any idea how long the Lane Committee is likely to take?

Sir K. Joseph

Yes, I have just said that I hope the report will be available later this year.

Mr. Robert Cooke

I am sure my right hon. Friend will agree that, what- ever the report says, the consequences of abortion have been tragic. Will he concentrate his thoughts on further advice on family planning which has an important bearing on this matter?

Sir K. Joseph

It was because the Government were so concerned about some aspects of abortion that the Lane Committee was set up. We eagerly await its advice.