HC Deb 26 January 1972 vol 829 cc1368-9
7. Mr. Ellis

asked the Secretary of State for the Environment if he will issue a general direction to British Railways to ensure the continued and efficient working of mineral-carrying branch lines when employment in industries served by such lines is immediately and directly affected by restriction of their working and in particular by their closure.

The Minister for Transport Industries (Mr. John Peyton)

No, Sir.

Mr. Ellis

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that in my constituency, which has a male unemployment rate of over 7 per cent., a local quarry company was obliged to dismiss 25 of its workmen because of a decision by British Railways first to increase substantially their charges for the carrying of minerals and, secondly, to close within a few months the branch line serving the quarry?

In view of the efforts which the Government claim they are making to improve the unemployment situation, may I ask the Minister to appreciate that a small but appropriate and simple remedy in this instance would be for him to have a word with British Railways and get them to agree, first, to keep; pen this branch line and, next, to reduce their exorbitant freight rates?

Mr. Peyton

While I have every sympathy with the background which the hon. Gentleman has outlined, I nevertheless have no powers to direct British Railways on this subject. It must be a management decision whether to withdraw a freight service, which in the instance which the hon. Gentleman has in mind, I believe, is totally unprofitable.