HC Deb 09 November 1971 vol 825 cc811-2
7. Mr. Greville Janner

asked the Secretary of State for Social Services whether he will require hospital boards and management committees to take steps to ensure that patients are enabled to die in the maximum privacy and with the minimum distress to other patients.

Mr. Alison

We have every reason to believe that hospital authorities and their staff are already fully aware of the need to meet these aims.

Mr. Janner

If the Minister believes that hospital authorities are aware of the need to do this, why is not something positive being done about it? Is it not the fact that in the majority of cases it is known when a patient is about to die? Is it not realised that when a patient dies without privacy, a great deal of quite unnecessary suffering is caused to people in adjoining beds? For the sake of the patient and others, steps should be taken along the lines suggested.

Mr. Alison

I appreciate the hon. and learned Gentleman's concern for the tragedy of terminal cases, but I ask him to recognise that he is not alone in this concern and that hospitals can be relied upon to feel the same sympathy and compassion for these cases as many of us in the House do. Everything is done to make them as happy as possible, and many of them prefer to go home or be taken away by their families.

Mr. Lipton

Is the hon. Gentleman aware that anyone who has ever been in a public ward, as I have, when a patient has died must be impressed by the self- restraint, dignity and respect shown to everyone concerned?

Mr. Alison

indicated assent.

Sir K. Joseph

indicated assent.

Forward to