HC Deb 02 December 1971 vol 827 cc641-2
27. Sir T. Beamish

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department if he will list the offences under the provisions of the reciprocal extradition agreement between the Irish Republic and the United Kingdom; whether he proposes to seek an extension of this agreement to include other offences; and if he will make a statement.

Mr. Maudling

Our extradition arrangements with the Irish Republic are based on reciprocal legislation which covers indictable offences and summary offences punishable on summary conviction with six months' imprisonment. I see no need to seek to extend these arrangements to lesser offences.

Sir T. Beamish

Is my right hon. Friend aware that, although this agreement on the face of it seems satisfactory, all too often its provisions can be frustrated in the Irish courts for what seem to be quite spurious reasons? Is he further aware that there is widespread and strong feeling about this matter and, although I do not ask him to comment in detail now, would he be kind enough to convey this view to the Irish Government?

Mr. Maudling

My hon. and gallant Friend voices a view that is well known in this country. It would be bad enough if I were to comment on the action of the courts in this country, but it would certainly be wrong and improper of me as Home Secretary to comment on the actions of courts in another country.

Mr. Chichester-Clark

Whether or not my right hon. Friend comments on this matter, will he at least consider setting on foot a study to look into how the practice of extradition is in conformity with the Irish Republic's own law, and indeed with international law? If necessary, will he consider taking this matter to the International Court of Justice?

Mr. Maudling

I would be prepared to consider any suggestion put to me that the arrangements are not satisfactory.