HC Deb 08 May 1967 vol 746 cc1054-5
48. Sir B. Janner

asked the Minister of Health what is the result of the reconsideration of the economics of staff at Cardiff in respect of the general practitioner maternity unit there; and whether, in view of this and the necessity of a similar unit being established in Leicester to serve the area around the General Hospital, he will take steps to ensure the installation of such a unit.

Mr. Snow

In 1966 the Cardiff Unit dealt with an average of six maternity cases per week, although it was planned for three times this number: as there must be staff on duty at all times, this has made it difficult to staff the unit economically. It is for the Sheffield Regional Hospital Board to decide whether a similar unit would be the best way in which to provide general practitioner maternity beds at the Leicester General Hospital, and when such provision can be made.

Sir B. Janner

Is not that a very unsatisfactory way of dealing with the matter? Is not the Minister aware that he himself, replying to a Question by myself last week, stated that he was in favour of this kind of treatment? As the medical profession, and particularly the medical profession in Leicester, think that it is an extremely useful service, and that it is economical, will he not go into the question himself and see that the Sheffield Board adopt it?

Mr. Snow

As for the last part of my hon. Friend's supplementary question, my right hon. Friend does not dictate to hospital regional boards what they will do. As to the economies of this experiment, I must tell my hon. Friend that the view is not held in my Department that this Cardiff unit experiment is undesirable but, on the contrary, that it should be encouraged, but as there had been a much smaller number of deliveries than was already planned there have had to be reductions in staff and the economic aspect has had to be watched.

Sir B. Janner

On a point of order, Mr. Speaker. In view of the unsatisfactory nature of the reply, I shall be forced at an early opportunity to raise the matter on the Adjournment.