HC Deb 19 June 1967 vol 748 cc1121-2
58. Mr. Christopher Price

asked the Minister of Health what action he is taking to prevent a repetition of the recent incident in a Birmingham hospital when a limb was amputated in error.

Mr. Snow

Hospital authorities have again been asked to review their procedures and to ensure that all staff concerned are made aware of them. My right hon. Friend will consider whether any further advice or guidance is called for when he receives the report of the inquiry to be held into the Birmingham incident.

Mr. Price

I thank my hon. Friend for that reply. Is he aware that we are very satisfied that this inquiry is being set up? However, as it is likely to take some time, together with possible litigation which may follow it, to what extent is the Ministry now examining the very great need to take a completely new look at the whole question of avoiding errors in hospital?

Mr. Snow

In 1966 the Royal College of Surgeons set up a committee on surgical accidents, with which my right hon. Friend's medical staff kept in close touch. The Committee came to the conclusion that the most effective contribution that the Royal College could make was through its normal educational facilities. As to the length of time which may pass whilst the inquiry is taking place and as a result of other things which may occur arising from that, I think my hon. Friend may rest assured that my right hon. Friend is deeply concerned about this incident.

Mr. Braine

How many such cases have been reported? I believe that there were seven in 1958 and nineteen last year. Is the number increasing? Has any analysis been made by the Department of the causes? Is there a common fact? For example, is it the fact that these incidents occur when there is an emergency and the surgeon who operates has not previously seen the patient? Is this a reflection of the increasing load on hospital doctors?

Mr. Snow

There are many imponderable factors as to the causation of these regrettable incidents. The figures for claims reported to my Department for wrong operations were three in 1962, ten in 1963, six in 1964, and seven in 1965. I should require notice before answering as to the cause of each individual case.