HC Deb 15 February 1967 vol 741 cc597-8
11. Mr. Buchanan-Smith

asked the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food if seals will be culled on the Farne Islands in 1967.

Mr. Peart

I am discussing this matter with the National Trust.

Mr. Buchanan-Smith

Will the Minister bear in mind that the damage to fishing on the East Coast of Scotland is estimated to be over £50,000 a year and that the scientific evidence is that the seals come from the Fame Islands? Will he take account of the interests of the fishing industry and consider this matter very seriously?

Mr. Peart

I already do so. I have been attacked for taking the same point of view as the hon. Gentleman on many occasions on this matter. I am glad of his support. But he will appreciate that I have no power to compel the National Trust to give its permission. The Trust owns the Farne Islands and it is better to try and get its co-operation.

Mr. Burden

Does not the right hon. Gentleman agree that although there may be damage for the fishing industry, we do not want to see culling become a yearly habit without real cause, and that very careful consideration should be given before it is allowed?

Mr. Peart

That is precisely the policy I have followed since I became Minister. We have carefully assessed the damage and the scientific evidence to try and balance all these factors.

Mr. Manuel

Is my right hon. Friend aware that a great body of opinion is against the slaughter of baby seals in the way that it has been going on? Many people are afraid that it may reach what can only be described as indiscriminate slaughter. Will my right hon. Friend be very careful in assessing what should be allowed?

Mr. Peart

I am always very careful and try to assess this matter impartially and independently. The animal welfare interests have to be considered and I take note of what my hon. Friend says. On the other hand, as Fisheries Minister, I recognise the problems of the fishing industry as well.