HC Deb 26 March 1963 vol 674 cc1107-8
25. Mrs. Slater

asked the Minister of Housing and Local Government and Minister for Welsh Affairs, if he will state his reasons for the designation of Stoke Station as a building of historic interest.

Mr. Corfield

My right hon. Friend proposes listing Stoke Station because it is a good example of mid-nineteenth century achitecture forming with the adjoining buildings a pleasant square.

Mrs. Slater

Is the hon. Gentleman aware that this station sadly needs modernising and that there is far too much dirt, drabness and untidiness about it? Is he aware that to schedule it as an historic building is sheer nonsense in the light of present conditions?

Mr. Corfield

The hon. Lady's supplementary question illustrates the difficulties. These are matters where opinions differ widely.

Mr. Swingler

Although Stoke Station may well be historic in the sense that it is a bit of a ruin, is that really any reason why the hon. Gentleman's Department should collaborate in perpetuating a totally insanitary building?

Dr. Stross

May I ask whether the Parliamentary Secretary realises that of course it is right to list this building because it is attractive from the outside, despite its dirt? Is he aware that it is the inside that needs modernising, and will he use his influence to help us?

Mr. Corfield

The hon. Gentleman will appreciate that that is somewhat outside the scope of my Department. I am grateful to him for drawing attention to the fact that we are concerned with the looks from the outside.