HC Deb 11 April 1962 vol 657 cc1304-5
33. Sir B. Janner

asked the Minister of Transport, in view of the importance of the extension of planting of shrubs or trees in the division between the two roads on the M.1 in order to prevent the type of accident which recently occurred, when he now intends that this planting shall be carried out.

Mr. Marples

I doubt whether the planting of shrubs or trees in the central reserve of M.1 would necessarily reduce the number and severity of accidents, although it may be useful for other purposes. We are, however, considering whether any other steps should be taken to prevent vehicles crossing the central reserve.

Sir B. Janner

Is the Minister aware that that is a very alarming reply? Is he aware that in America and Holland shrubs have been planted and that the hedges which arise prevent very serious accidents? Cars can be stopped within a few yards, even though they are travelling at a very fast pace? Is he not prepared in these circumstances to save life and limb, and incidentally prevent dazzle, but ensuring that shrubs are planted straight away? Will he investigate the matter?

Mr. Marples

I have already investigated it and I have asked the Americans for details of their experience. The American experience of central safety fences indicates that these might cause more accidents than they prevent, due to vehicles colliding with the fence.

Mr. Gresham Cooke

Although safety fences may have their defects, is my right hon. Friend aware that the rambler rose bushes in America have been extremely successful and have been planted free of charge in many places by nurserymen who are glad to have the prestige from doing so?

Mr. Marples

Yes. That is why I said in answer to an earlier supplementary question that we were inquiring into the question of what could be placed in the central reservation.

Mr. Dance

Will not my right hon. Friend reconsider the decision he gave when I asked him a supplementary question some time ago about continuing this anti-dazzle screen along the M.1? I can assure him that all users of the road have found great—

Mr. Speaker

Order. We have dealt with screens. I think that the hon. Gentleman was not here then. This Question is about shrubs and trees.

Sir B. Janner

Is the Minister prepared to go further into this matter without delay? As the planting of shrubs and trees has proved very succesful in some parts, as has already been confirmed by the hon. Member for Twickenham (Mr. Gresham Cooke), does he not think that he should start on this job straight away so that within two or three years accidents will be prevented?

Mr. Marples

I will consider any evidence the hon. Gentleman cares to give me which he has from America or elsewhere. I give him my word that I will look at it closely.