HC Deb 02 May 1957 vol 569 cc364-5
44. Mr. Philips Price

asked the Prime Minister whether, consequent upon continuance by the Egyptian Government of obstruction to the plans of the Canal Users' Association for the working of the Canal and to the right of Israeli ships to free passage of the Canal and the Gulf of Aqaba, he will have plans prepared after consultation with the Governments of Kenya, Uganda, and Tanganyika, to exclude Egypt from any increase in water supply from the headwaters of the Nile and Lake Victoria Nyanza.

The Prime Minister (Mr. Harold Macmillan)

No, Sir. This is a complex matter, but I am not persuaded that Her Majesty's Government's policy should be based on the linking of these two questions.

Mr. Price

Would it not be desirable to show Colonel Nasser that we, too, have some cards that we can play?

The Prime Minister

Yes, Sir; I think that the putting of this Question on the Order Paper has demonstrated that fact.

Mr. Bevan

But is that quite enough? Is not it true that Egypt has been a beneficiary of international co-operation in securing the withdrawal of French, Israeli and British troops from Egyptian territory? Is it not therefore perfectly proper that we should consider international action in order to secure that Egypt should have regard to other people's opinions?

The Prime Minister

Yes, but I was asked whether I would consider what would really amount to a breach of the agreement of 1929. That is rather too serious a question to deal with by way of Question and Answer. I indicated that in my view these matters were not necessarily linked.

Mr. Bevan

But is not there apprehension in some quarters that Egypt might be the recipient of economic aid from certain nations without first observing international regulations?

The Prime Minister

That is quite another question. This is a question whether we should abrogate the agreement of 1929.

Mr. J. Griffiths

Will the Prime Minister bear in mind that when, under the colonial development and welfare scheme, we developed the Owen Falls project in Uganda, we consulted and came to an agreement with Egypt, and observed their interests, and that they might now reciprocate?

The Prime Minister

Yes, I think so. indeed.

Forward to