HC Deb 28 March 1955 vol 539 cc30-1
61. Captain Pilkington

asked the Minister of Health if he is aware that members of friendly societies, some of whom have contributed for nearly 50 years, are at a disadvantage under the Health Service in regard to dental benefits, in that whereas previously they paid in for, and received, the full cost of new dentures, they now receive only half the cost; and if he will take steps to enable members of friendly societies to receive new dentures free of charge.

Miss Hornsby-Smith

The position of these members has been much improved by the provision of more valuable insurance benefits and comprehensive Health Services. It would not be practicable to discriminate in their favour in respect of the comparatively few charges to patients, nor has my right hon. Friend any powers which would allow him to do so.

Captain Pilkington

While appreciating the improvements which have been made, may I ask my hon. Friend whether she is aware that there is a very real sense of grievance here? Will she look into the matter again if I give her further details?

Miss Hornsby-Smith

It is not a question of looking into it again. The powers of my right hon. Friend are limited. He cannot make a discriminatory preference in the case of certain members who in a very few societies were able to obtain this benefit when they had large surpluses accrue.

Forward to