HC Deb 20 December 1955 vol 547 cc1835-6
34. Mr. McGovern

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland the cause of the recent hunger strike in Peterhead Prison, the number of men involved and the results; the cause of the revolt at the quarries and what punishment was inflicted on the prisoners; and if he is prepared to order a public inquiry into the various complaints and revolts in this prison, and appoint a more understanding and suitable governor and head warder.

Mr. J. Stuart

On 18th November one prisoner assaulted an officer in the quarry. The matter was remitted to the visiting committee, and I am awaiting their report. On 21st and 22nd November, different groups of prisoners refused one or more meals during a period of 28 hours. The maximum number who refused any one meal was 62 out of 223 men at this prison. Members of the visiting committee who investigated the matter found no special ground for complaint, but recommended that an attempt be made to make the diet rather more varied. I see no reason for a public inquiry, and I have every confidence in the governor and officers.

Mr. McGovern

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware of the number of complaints which have come to me regarding this prison and that a constituent of mine raised the question of the type and quantity of food previous to the hunger strike and was immediately put in solitary confinement? Does not he think that the visiting committee investigation is rather out of date? Surely, in the interests of discipline in prisons, prison officers should not have a closed mind on this matter, as would appear to be evidenced by the governor and head warder of the prison? Could not the right hon. Gentleman do something to see that prisoners are allowed to voice their legitimate grievances, and is not a more intimate method of investigation necessary?

Mr. Stuart

I think the visiting committee procedure a very fair arrangement. The committee has access to all parts of the prison and all persons and can hear complaints. While perhaps the food in prison may not be what everyone would prefer, that also has been considered, and the governor and head warder are men of long experience.