HC Deb 21 December 1954 vol 535 cc2580-1
18. Mr. Hannan

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland if he is aware of the anxieties of parents and the strain on children imposed by the promotion examination from primary to secondary schools; and if he will consult the local education authorities with a view to providing an alternative to this test.

Mr. J. Stuart

There is no evidence of serious or widespread anxiety or strain. The aim of promotion schemes is to find the right type of course for each pupil, and the decision on this is based not only on the results of the tests applied but also on other factors, such as an estimate by the primary school teacher of the pupil's capacity. Promotion schemes are kept under review by the authorities and the Department, and the authorities regard the present arrangements as generally satisfactory.

Mr. Hannan

The Question asked if the right hon. Gentleman would consult local authorities. Is he correctly informed upon this matter; and, further, is he aware that the fact that children are being segregated at this early age is creating great concern? Does not he agree that it is a bad thing, socially and educationally, to segregate these children at such an early age and put them into different schools?

Mr. Stuart

I am not a confirmed believer in the principle that everybody must pass examinations. I do not think that it is necessary. I was never particularly successful myself. I think that many perfectly good people come through without coming top in examinations. I shall certainly bear in mind what the hon. Members says. We are, of course, in close consultation with the authorities.