HC Deb 11 June 1953 vol 516 cc449-50
44. Mr. de Freitas

asked the Minister of Agriculture whether he will introduce legislation so that in any future marketing scheme poll the views of the small farmers shall be adequately represented.

Sir T. Dugdale

No, Sir. I see no reason to think that the present Acts fail to provide for adequate representation of the views of small farmers.

Mr. de Freitas

Is the Minister aware that in the recent fruit poll the views of the majority of farmers failed merely because the minority comprised farmers with the larger area?

Sir T. Dugdale

No, I do not accept that. Only about 11,000 out of 17,000 registered producers voted. Had the small producers voted for the scheme in large numbers it would probably have gone through.

Mr. de Freitas

Would the Minister accept my supplementary if instead of "the majority of farmers" I said that the majority of those voting failed against a minority who voted because that minority had the larger area?

Sir T. Dugdale

No, I cannot accept that. The present legislation on this point has been approved by all parties and I think it would be the greatest mistake to alter it. A two-thirds majority, in both numbers and acreage, is required in respect of any particular commodity. I believe that that is sufficient in the interests of all concerned.

Mr. G. Brown

Was not the real trouble with the recent scheme that even had it gone through it would not have been a marketing scheme, so it did not attract anybody's attention?