HC Deb 27 April 1953 vol 514 cc1755-6
43. Sir H. Williams

asked the Minister of Transport whether, in view of fire disasters to modern ships, he will consider the appointment of a committee to study methods of ship design which will reduce the risk of such disasters in future.

Mr. Braithwaite

This matter was exhaustively considered at the International Conference on Safety of Life at Sea, 1948, when much higher international standards were agreed upon. These were embodied in the Safety Convention, which came into operation on 19th November last.

These higher standards apply to new ships, but British ships have, for some years, come up to them and have a very high degree of protection against fire.

Sir H. Williams

Is it not a fact that there have been two recent major disasters through fires on ships? Is it not time that further action was taken?

Mr. Braithwaite

I imagine that my hon. Friend has in mind the "Empress of Canada" and the "Queen Elizabeth" fires. In the case of the first, this was a very old ship, not fitted with sprinklers, but in the case of the "Queen Elizabeth," the fact that the fire was dealt with immediately and effectively and did not become serious was emphatic evidence of the improvements which have now been introduced.

Sir H. Williams

What about the Danish ship?

Mr. Braithwaite

The Danes are in vestigating that.

Mr. Hobson

Is it not a fact that these standards are not obligatory?

Mr. Braithwaite

Under the Convention, yes.