HC Deb 04 February 1952 vol 495 c620
16. Mr. J. Grimond

asked the Minister of Fuel and Power whether he will give further consideration to the sale of coal at a uniform price throughout Britain.

Mr. Geoffrey Lloyd

No, Sir.

Mr. Grimond

Does not the Minister think that a uniform price is one of the advantages which we might expect from nationalisation; that it would make for a considerable saving in accountancy; and that it would be a factor in encouraging the better distribution of industry throughout Great Britain?

Mr. Lloyd

No, Sir. I appreciate that these reasons can be advanced, but the hon. Gentleman ought also to consider the fact that great industries in this country have grown up near the coalfields and that they rely upon cheap coal.

Mr. Hector Hughes

If there can be a uniform price for cigarettes, beer and other commodities all over this island, why cannot there be a uniform price for coal? Is the Minister aware that in this respect the North of Scotland is penalised by its geographical position and can he not allow coal to be sold to the people there at the same price as it is sold to people in the South of England?

Mr. Lloyd

One of the principal reasons is that coal weighs very much more and is much more bulky than cigarettes.