HC Deb 18 April 1950 vol 474 cc29-30
49. Sir H. Williams

asked the Prime Minister whether he is aware that Statutory Instrument No. 297 of 1950 was signed by the Minister of National Insurance in that capacity seven days before her acceptance of that office; and whether he will take stops to avoid a recurrence of such an incident.

The Prime Minister

The hon. Member is, I am afraid, under a misapprehension. The ceremony of kissing of hands, to which I assume he refers, is the traditional manner in which a subject returns thanks for and acknowledges at His Majesty's convenience an honour or favour conferred upon him. It has no significance in relation to the acceptance of the ministerial office in question. If acceptance of the office is necessary to constitute an effective appointment-and this is a matter of considerable doubt acceptance in fact took place before the signature of the Statutory Instrument referred to by the hon. Member.

Sir H. Williams

In what way does the date become known on which a Minister is effectively appointed?

The Prime Minister

In this case the Minister took the oath of office required under the Promissory Oaths Act before the Lord President on 2nd March. On 28th February formal approval was given. The Statutory Instrument was signed on 7th March. The Minister's audience by the King was held on 15th March. There was nothing done here which was not in the ordinary course of events.

Sir H. Williams

Is not the Prime Minister aware that the authoritative publication on this matter, Halsbury's "Laws of England," commits itself to the statement that the acceptance of office is indicated by the kissing of the King's hand, and is he aware, therefore, that his statement today is in complete conflict with that authoritative document?

The Prime Minister

I am afraid I do not know that particular document, but I have consulted the highest authorities on this matter. The hon. Gentleman is entirely wrong on the matter of kissing hands. He is confusing that with what happens in connection with certain offices when there is the handing over of the seals.