HC Deb 02 March 1949 vol 462 cc343-4
24. Mr. Niall Macpherson

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Civil Aviation whether, in view of the further information supplied by the hon. Member for Dumfries, he will now make a further statement in regard to Clairways, Limited.

Mr. Lindgren

I regret that when I spoke in the House on 26th January, I used the term "official receiver" in relation to C.L. Air Surveys, Limited. I understand that the true position is that the debenture holder of the company has put in a receiver and manager.

Mr. Macpherson

While I accept the expression of regret of the hon. Gentleman—which, I think, might have gone a little further—is he aware that it is not really in accord with the traditions of this House to make a scurrilous attack at the very last minute of an Adjournment Debate, when it cannot be replied to, and will he give a full apology for that attack?

Mr. Lindgren

I do not think it is a scurrilous attack to use the term "official receivers"—which, I agree, relates to a compulsory winding up—when I should have used the term "receiver and manager." But if the debenture holder has put in a receiver and manager I do not think anything I said can do much more harm.

Mr. Macpherson

The hon. Gentleman still has left the impression that the company is being wound up, which is very far from the case. It is a going concern. [An HON. MEMBER: "Where is it going?"] Is the hon. Gentleman aware that it is a going concern and is being run successfully?

Mr. Lindgren

If it is so successful, why is the debenture holder so doubtful that he puts in a receiver and manager?