§ 41. Mr. Rankinasked the Secretary of State for the Colonies if he is aware that whipping is in force in Aden for juveniles and that they are herded in prison with adults; and what provision is being made for Borstal accommodation to segregate them.
Mr. Creech JonesJuveniles are still committed to prison in Aden and power still exists to punish offenders with a light cane. I am advised that they are segregated at all times from other prisoners and that they have their own sleeping quarters with exercise yard attached. The great majority of sentences are of short duration. I am discussing whether some other form of treatment would be appropriate.
§ Mr. RankinCan my right hon. Friend tell us how light is the cane, and if there is any provision in the 10-year plan for Aden for new prisons where segregation may take place which, according to my information, is not now taking place?
Mr. Creech JonesThe juveniles are segregated, and there has been issued from my Office a circular giving directions to local governments in regard to the treatment of juvenile offenders. Most Governments are following the course recommended.
§ Mr. GallacherIs the right hon. Gentleman aware that the cane is a brutal method of punishment and, more than that, does no good, because I was caned very often when I was a boy?
§ Sir Stanley ReedWill the right hon. Gentleman accept the assurance of those who have had magisterial experience of juvenile offenders of this sort, that those who have been subjected to a light whipping practically never appear again in court and those who are sentenced to gaol nearly always become confirmed criminals?