HC Deb 25 January 1949 vol 460 cc735-6
37. Mr. Spearman

asked the Minister of Town and Country Planning if he will publish the full report on the recent inquiry that led to his decision to use Fylingdale Moor as a training centre.

Mr. Silkin

The publication of confidential reports such as this made to a Minister to assist him in coming to a decision, has for long been regarded as undesirable, and I see no reason for making an exception in this case.

Mr. Spearman

In view of the very strong local opposition to this decision, does not the Minister think it would be fair to publish all the facts which actuated that decision; and will he also publish particulars of the alternative sites which were considered before it was decided to accept this area for a training ground?

Mr. Silkin

This matter was not decided in a hole-and-corner manner. There was a public inquiry, and the evidence is public property. We have published the letter which actuated our decision, and, therefore, the public have all the information available.

Mr. Granville Sharp

Can my right hon. Friend say to what extent the public will be denied access to this part of the proposed national park area?

Mr. Silken

That is another question. If the hon. Member will put it down, I will answer it.

Mr. Turton

In view of the fact that this is a large part of a national park area, will the Minister place a report of the proceedings in the Library so that hon. Members can read it before the Debate on the National Parks Bill?

Mr. Silkin

That is exactly the question I have answered.

Mr. Turton

I am asking the right hon. Gentleman if he will place in the Library for hon. Members of this House, and not for publication, the proceedings of the inquiry?

Mr. Silkin

I am not prepared to do that.