HC Deb 01 March 1948 vol 448 cc20-1
42. Mr. Skinnard

asked the Minister of Transport whether he will introduce legislation to extend the privilege of late workmen's tickets for shift workers to such workers as private firemen.

Mr. Barnes

No, Sir. The issue of late workmen's tickets is a concession outside the scope of statutory requirements. So far as the British Transport Commission's services are concerned it is a matter for them and I am bringing my hon. Friend's Question to their attention.

Mr. Skinnard

Is the Minister aware that the original classes to which this concession was given were defined by legislation and, as private firemen are an important part of any shift, especially in such places as newspaper offices, is it not invidious that they have to pay full fares while other people on the same shift who are no more necessary than they, get the advantage of workman's tickets?

Mr. Barnes

Any extension of this facility beyond the statutory requirements raises very difficult and complex issues and should be the subject of careful examination, probably with a view to any change in the schedule of charges.

Mr. Skinnard

Can the Minister inform the House how soon the matter will be discussed by the Transport Commission with a view to such changes being made?

Mr. Barnes

The matter is being examined now. It is a most complex problem.

Mr. Boyd-Carpenter

When the right hon. Gentleman has brought this to the attention of the Transport Commission and they have come to a decision, will the House be informed.

Mr. Barnes

Obviously.

Mr. W. J. Brown

Might we ask the Minister to request the Transport Commission to reconsider the whole matter of the arbitrary differentiation between one type of individual and another, as, for example, between workmen and clerks?

Mr. Barnes

That supports the point I was making, that this will have far-reaching consequences. The whole question of fares and charges will have to be subject to the most careful examination. That process is taking place at the moment.