HC Deb 08 December 1948 vol 459 cc383-4
43. Mr. Henderson Stewart

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Admiralty if he is aware of the disappointment caused in Scotland by the decision to close down the boys' naval training establishment at Crail, in view of the fact that its establishment last year provided for the first time for the training of boys for the Royal Navy in Scotland; and what steps are to be taken to maintain recruiting of Scottish boys for the Royal Navy.

Mr. W. Edwards

I am aware that a decision such as this could not have been taken without causing some disappointment in Scotland. But I am conscious, too, that Scotsmen would not readily acquiesce in the expense of a naval establishment after it had fulfilled its purpose. I see no reason to expect that the closing of this establishment will affect the rate of recruitment of Scottish boys who like others are attracted rather by the prospects of a good career in the Royal Navy than by the very temporary convenience of spending their first year in an establishment near their homes.

Mr. Henderson Stewart

Does the hon. Gentleman recollect the pride with which his hon. Friend the Parliamentary Secretary announced the establishment of this station some 18 months ago on the ground that it gave Scotland a training centre for boys, and if it was right then how does it come to be so wrong now?

Mr. Edwards

I am certain that everyone in the House was quite proud of the fact that Scotland was to have a training centre for boys, but it was explained at that time that it was only to be of a temporary nature. I would point out to the hon. Member that the main reason why this establishment can no longer continue as a boys' training establishment is because of the pressure being used to send as many men to sea as possible, and, in this connection, over 200 officers and men have been released for sea service.