HC Deb 27 April 1948 vol 450 cc203-4
40. Sir David Robertson

asked the Secretary of State for War if, in view of the facts disclosed in a recent case, with which he is familiar, he will make a new rule detailing an officer to be present when a member of the A.T.S. is under interrogation by the civil police.

Mr. Shinwell

A soldier or auxiliary has the right of any citizen interviewed by the police to decline to answer questions or to ask for the attendance of a friend or legal representative. No special arrangement seems necessary for the A.T.S.

Sir D. Robertson

But is it not the duty of an officer to protect those he is privileged to command? Why should there be any difficulty in providing these young girls of 18 and 19 years of age with someone who can protect them at a time when they are subjected to an interrogation which savours of the third degree?

Mr. Shinwell

I can assure the hon. Member that, in the case which I think gives rise to this Question, the girl had the opportunity of being furnished with some friend who could advise her. In all cases we permit that to happen. There is no question of third degree.

Sir D. Robertson

Is the right hon. Gentleman telling the House that before this young girl was summarily brought in for examination by a police officer, her company officer said to her, "You can send for a friend or legal adviser"? With great respect, I cannot accept that answer.

Mr. Shinwell

According to the information supplementing what I have said, if the auxiliary had asked for the presence of an officer, her request would have been granted immediately. In fact, an officer was waiting in a nearby room in case she was wanted.