HC Deb 14 April 1948 vol 449 cc951-2
21. Mr. Stokes

asked the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs how many factories still remain to be dismantled in the British zone of Germany under the level of industry plan.

Mr. Bevin

Two hundred and twenty-three plants.

Mr. Stokes.

Is it or is it not the fact that in the American zone dismantling of all but purely war plants has ceased, and in view of the fact that our programme means that 30, 000 men at this end are destroying work for 50,000 men, is it not time that this policy was reconsidered, especially in view of the changed circumstances in Europe?

Mr. Bevin

When we enter into agreements with other countries, including our Allies, I do not think it is wise, through the mere momentary change of circumstances, unilaterally to alter our obligations. We have to remember that Germany over-ran France, Belgium, Holland and other countries, and if the hon. Gentleman is willing to excuse that and not make any reparations, I am afraid His Majesty's Government cannot agree.

Mr. Stokes

But is my right hon. Friend aware that that really is not the point at all? Is he aware that what he is actually doing is destroying things for which in due course this country will have to pay to rebuild?