HC Deb 19 March 1947 vol 435 cc402-3
47. Mr. Blackburn

asked the Prime Minister whether Field-Marshal Montgomery had the permission of the Government to make a speech on 15th March containing his views on the political and economic situation; and whether he will take steps to ensure that Field-Marshal Montgomery does not express political views again while holding the office of Chief of the Imperial General Staff.

The Prime Minister

The Chief of the Imperial General Staff was invited by his hosts at the dinner of the London Association of Engineers to say some words on the subject of leadership, team work and hard work. He has explained to me that he had no intention of making a political speech, but desired to emphasise to the Engineers points in the campaign of the Government for increased production which had already been made by Ministers in pronouncements on the economic situation of the country. He has expressed to me his great regret that some newspapers should have imputed to him the intention of criticising the Government, a thing which never entered his mind.

Mr. Blackburn

As such comment was made on a previous occasion, may I say that I entirely accept the statement made by my right hon. Friend? May I ask, however, whether he is aware that there is no intention to disparage Field-Marshal Montgomery, but merely to point out that it is important that commanders should not appear to approach doing things which, if done by their subordinates, would be unlawful?

Viscount Hinchingbrooke

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that the conviction that it is constitutionally improper for the Chief of the Imperial General Staff to make a speech bearing political implications is not confined to one side of the House, and will he give the House the assurance that the present holder of that office fully comprehends the position?

The Prime Minister

I entirely agree with the noble Lord. It is highly undesirable that anyone holding such a position should make a political speech. I have spoken to the Chief of the Imperial General Staff, pointing out the danger of making speeches which might be misinterpreted by persons who want to make mischief, and that applies to some organs of the Press.

Mr. Collins

Would my right hon. Friend convey to the Chief of the Imperial General Staff that the best contribution he could make to production would be to cut down the wastage of manpower in the Army to a minimum?

Brigadier Peto

Is the Prime Minister aware that Field-Marshal Montgomery was merely trying to portray to the country what millions in this country think—that we lack leadership?